Up to date: November 4, 2020 7:34:38 pm
The sugar trade has reacted strongly to Union Commerce and Trade Minister Piyush Goyal’s announcement that the central authorities just isn’t contemplating an extension of its export subsidy for the 2020-21 sugar season. The trade has warned of a ‘vertical collapse’ within the sector as a result of extreme inventory, whose ramification will be felt within the years to come back. Right here’s why this difficulty has shaken the sugar trade earlier than the beginning of an in any other case good season.
Why is the sugar trade rooting for exports even earlier than the beginning of the season?
Initially of the (October-November) sugar season, the trade attracts up its balance-sheet and takes into consideration the anticipated manufacturing, the carry ahead inventory of final season, minus home consumption and exports, if any. This sugar balance-sheet determines the provision of sugar for the following season. In case of unusually excessive inventory, ex-mill costs stay low for the current season in addition to for the upcoming season, which end in liquidity disaster for the sugar sector.
For the season which has began, the annual manufacturing is estimated to be 326 lakh tonne (with none diversion in the direction of ethanol), and the season has began with opening inventory of 107 lakh tonne.
Nonetheless, trade sources estimate sugar manufacturing being decrease by 20 lakh tonne as mills are anticipated to supply ethanol, and thus the full out there sugar steadiness on this season is predicted to be 413 lakh tonne. After deducting the home consumption of 260 lakh tonne, the opening inventory of subsequent season (season of 2021-22) is estimated to be 155 lakh tonne.
This unusually excessive inventory, with out an export incentive like a authorities subsidy, will end in a ‘vertical collapse of the sector’, mentioned Prakash Naiknavare, managing director of the Nationwide Federation of Cooperative Sugar Factories Restricted.
A technique of correcting this stock is to advertise export of a minimum of 50 lakh tonne of sugar, prompt Naiknavare. Sugar mills export each white in addition to uncooked (unrefined sugar which is brownish in color) sugar. If 50 lakh tonne of sugar is shipped in a foreign country, the opening inventory can be 105 lakh tonne, offering the mills a wholesome stock in addition to liquidity from exports. 📣 Click to follow Express Explained on Telegram
Why are mills reluctant to export sugar with out a authorities subsidy?
The mills’ reluctance stems from the hole between price of producing and the present worth of uncooked sugar in worldwide markets. Sugar contracts at worldwide markets are buying and selling at Rs 21-22 per kg, whereas the price of manufacturing is at Rs 32. The worth mismatch has dominated out any export prospects as this may result in additional loss for the mills.
Satirically, mills are going through this drawback at a time when Indian sugar has made its mark within the worldwide markets. Final season, India has reported document sugar export of 60 lakh tonne, of which 57 lakh tonne have already left the the nation. The remaining consignment is predicted to depart by the top of December.
Aside from the standard markets of Bangladesh, Malayasia and Sri Lanka, Indian mills have additionally shipped their produce to newer international locations like Iran, China, South Korea and Somalia.
Don’t miss from Defined | Behind the suspension of goods trains in Punjab, farm protests — and politics
How did the mills handle to export sugar final season?
The document export degree final season was doable solely due to the subsidy programme supplied by the central authorities. Mills had been promised a transport subsidy of Rs 10.448 per kg of sugar exported. This subsidy had helped mills bridge the distinction between manufacturing prices and worldwide costs. Additionally, the Union Ministry of Meals and Civil Provides was strict about compliance, which led to mills toeing the road when it comes to exports.The next demand in worldwide markets had additionally seen Indian mills reporting good exports.
Nonetheless, final week, Goyal dominated out any extension of the subsidy scheme because the worldwide sugar state of affairs is at the moment secure. Trade watches mentioned the delay in India’s export subsidy scheme had seen sugar costs rallying, and the profit is basically being drawn by Brazil, which is the most important sugar producer of the world.
As a second Covid-19-induced lockdown looms giant over Europe, Brazilian mills are contemplating diverting 48 per cent of their cane in the direction of sugar manufacturing, a lot larger than the sooner 35 per cent they had been planning to.
Have final season’s exports helped mills generate sufficient liquidity?
No. The central authorities is but to launch the export subsidy because of the mills and the full due is as excessive as Rs 6,900 crore. Particular person mills had taken loans to facilitate exports and now they must to pay curiosity to the banks. Unpaid curiosity of Rs 3,000 crore for sustaining buffer inventory has additionally hit exhausting the steadiness sheet of mills.
The Covid-19 pandemic has additional delayed the discharge of subsidy, which has led to many mills not having enough liquidity at first of the season.
Naiknavare identified how the sugar sector didn’t get any point out within the fiscal packages introduced by Union Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman to spice up the economic system. “The fixed prodding of the central authorities had prompted the mills to export, however now they’re caught. Additionally the minister’s (Goyal’s) current pronouncement has despatched jitters throughout the trade, which is cautious of one other season of liquidity crunch forward of it,” he mentioned.
However why can’t mills think about ethanol manufacturing, given the federal government’s emphasis on the gasoline additive?
Final week, the central authorities has introduced a Rs 1-3 per litre rise within the procurement worth of ethanol. That is the second sign given by the federal government to mills to divert cane in the direction of manufacturing of ethanol slightly than sugar. The trade has estimated that this yr, almost 20 lakh tonne of sugar might be diverted in the direction of producing ethanol. Final yr, the central authorities had introduced an curiosity subvention scheme for mills to enhance manufacturing of ethanol.
However diversion to ethanol, though a much-needed transfer, would require time to materialise. With the current capability, mills can produce 426 crore litres of ethanol, which might require diversion of 15-20 lakh tonnes of sugar.
“Whereas the federal government’s transfer to encourage mills in the direction of ethanol manufacturing is definitely welcome, it might require extra capital and time. For the present season, in case exports should not made viable, not solely will India lose its market share, however mills will definitely really feel the liquidity crunch. The impact of this might be disastrous for the sector,” mentioned Naiknavare.
📣 The Indian Categorical is now on Telegram. Click on here to join our channel (@indianexpress) and keep up to date with the most recent headlines
© The Indian Categorical (P) Ltd